Clean or Dirty? A Systematic Review of Splash Basin Use and Its Infectious Potential in Orthopaedic Surgery.
Academic Article
Overview
abstract
BACKGROUND: Splash basins are used in orthopaedic surgery cases to wash and hold instrumentsintraoperatively. This systematic review aims to summarize information on contamination of splash basins intraoperatively. METHODS: A systematic review was conducted using the following search terms: "splash basin" or "splash bucket." Two authors independently reviewed the literature. Studies were included if they reported on intraoperative splash basin contamination rates. Studies were excluded if they were not relevant to orthopaedic surgery, non-English articles, or repeat studies yielded by different online databases. RESULTS: There were seven studies included in this review. The median contamination rate of sterile water or physiologic saline splash basins was 23.9% [range: 2%-74%]. The addition of surgical antiseptics to sterile water splash basins was associated with 0% contamination rates in two studies. The most frequent splash basin contaminants identified in bacterial culture were coagulase negative staphylococcus (50%) and staphylococcus aureus (10%). CONCLUSION: The splash basin appears to be a frequent source of contamination in the operating room. Many studies suggest abandoning splash basin use altogether, although the efficacy of alternative methods such as cleaning instruments with lap pads in avoiding contamination of the sterile field has not been studied. Further investigation into surgical teams' use of the splash basin and the contents of the splash basin as they relate to contamination rates may help advance our understanding of optimal use of this surgical tool. Shorter case durations and dilute surgical antiseptics in splash basins appear associated with lower splash basin contamination risk. Level of Evidence: V.
