Does administration of chemotherapy before radiotherapy in breast cancer patients treated with conservative surgery negatively impact local control?

Overview

abstract

PURPOSE: To determine if a delay of irradiation to the intact breast for administration of adjuvant chemotherapy results in increased local recurrence in breast cancer. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The records of 262 women with 264 cases of breast cancer were reviewed. Group I contained 105 patients treated with conservative surgery, chemotherapy, and radiotherapy. Group II contained 157 patients (used as a concurrent control) treated with conservative surgery and radiotherapy only. Eighty-nine percent of subjects in group I received all chemotherapy before radiotherapy. Fifty-eight percent of patients received hormone therapy. Seventy-one percent of patients had negative surgical margins, and 74% had negative lymph nodes. For group I, conservative surgery-radiotherapy intervals in months were less than 1 (five, 5%), > or = 1 to less than 3 (10, 9%), > or = 1 to less 6 (48, 46%), and > or = 6 (42, 40%), mean of 5. For group II, the intervals were less than 1 (20, 13%), > or = 1 to less than 3 (123, 79%), > or = 3 to less than 6 (11, 7%), and > or = 6 (two, 1%), mean of 1.5. RESULTS: Thirty patients (11.5%) have disease recurrence (19 distant [6%] and 12 local [5%]). There were no significant differences in local recurrence (group I, four [4%]; group II, eight [5%]; difference not significant). There were no significant differences in local recurrence in any surgery-radiotherapy interval within each group. Although we found marginal increases in the percentage of local recurrences in group I patients (with prolonged surgery-radiotherapy intervals) who had positive margins, positive lymph nodes, and tumor size more than 2 cm versus group II (without prolonged surgery-radiotherapy intervals), these results were not significant. CONCLUSION: We could not identify any surgery-radiotherapy interval that resulted in increased local recurrence if radiotherapy was delayed for administration of adjuvant chemotherapy in breast cancer patients. Because of the heterogenous population of breast cancer patients, our results also support the need for further study to determine the optimum integration of radiotherapy and chemotherapy in the management of the conservatively treated breast.